Who does it better? Book, movie or Broadway?


There’s something magical about seeing your favorite stories come to life on stage or screen. However, when it comes to deciding which version is better, sometimes one of them doesn’t make the cut. Read on below to see which literary work takes its success to the stage and film.


Roald Dahl’s classic features a precocious youngster battling the bullies in her life, mainly being her parents and the school principal. In 1988, this book received the Children’s Book Award and is still very much in the forefront of popular culture as a cult classic. Matilda’s indignation at not being recognized as the genius she is has universal appeal because at some point we have all felt that our value was not truly understood by others. The film adaptation of the book came out in 1996 to a three-star review by Roger Ebert. “Matilda the Musical,” currently playing on Broadway, has taken this extraordinary tale to a new level. It has won four Tony Awards and a record-breaking seven Olivier Awards in London, where the play began.

In this instance, it’s hard to pick who did it better because the book, film and play beautifully capture the heart of the story. However, because the musical amps up the already rich plot, we would recommend getting your seats to this fun and exciting adventure.


Originally gleaned from “A Thousand and One Nights,” which is sometimes known as the “Arabian Nights,” the tale of Aladdin is one of the many that Scheherazade spun night after night to prevent her execution. The original tale is woven throughout a series of other occurrences that Disney capitalizes on in later editions of the story, such as “Aladdin and the Forty Thieves.” However, the original story is bit rougher around the edges when compared to the Disney version. The film version does a great job of capturing the magic of discovering that wealth alone doesn’t solve our desire to connect with others. The Broadway version kicks it up a notch and creates a breathtaking experience with beautifully choreographed music, sets and design.

In this case, it’s hard to compare the original story with the film and Broadway version as many elements of the story are lost in translation. So if you are looking for the authentic, albeit harsher version, the original tale is worth a read. But if it’s magic you’re after, Broadway and the film do it better.

American Psycho

The novel of the same name was published in 1991 and features an attractive young professional living a secret life as a serial killer. The movie, which came out in 2000, received critical reviews from the critic Roger Ebert, describing Bateman as a self-involved narcissistic man, intent on killing to fulfill his every dream and to polish his already over-glossed ego.

The musical version of “American Psycho” promises much of the same gruesome killing, with strobe lights and effects to tantalize and horrify. While the book is chilling and the film is perfectly disturbing, the musical falls short of impressing audiences. The recommendation here would be to stick to the classic.

There you have it, three tales and three versions, which will you pick?


sw otel

Disney is opening a Star Wars Hotel

(From The Independent) Star Wars fans will soon be able to play their part in an interactive adventure inspired by the film franchise, as a new Star Wars inspired resort has been confirmed by head honchos at Disney. The hotel w...
by Adword Norton


Behind the scenes peek at ‘Avatar’ World

(From Geeks of Doom) An expansion to Disney’s Animal Kingdom inspired by director James Cameron‘s blockbuster hit Avatar was first announced during the D23 Expo back in 2013, with more information coming out of the D23 Expo...
by Adword Norton


John Turturro is directing a Big Lebowski spin-off

(From Vanity Fair) John Turturro’s latest project, a film he wrote and will direct titled Going Places, is actually a Big Lebowski spin-off, according to reports. Inspired by the 1974 French film Les Valseuses, Going Places w...
by Adword Norton



Lego’s next minifigure collection features Disney’s characters

There’s only one thing that could make Legos better while also making them smaller, and that’s Disney. The popular lineup of teeny-tiny Lego Minifigures is expanding to include some of the most beloved Walt Disney c...
by Adword Norton


New details about the Star Wars theme parks

(From The Independent) Disney has offered a first, real glimpse of the Star Wars land set to open at Disneyland in Anaheim and Disney’s Hollywood Studios at Walt Disney Resort in Orlando. Forming part of ABC’s telev...
by Adword Norton



Be the first to comment!

Bir Cevap Yazın

E-posta hesabınız yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir


Şu HTML etiketlerini ve özelliklerini kullanabilirsiniz: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>